Dry Plate Photography

Exposure Fine-tuning and Troubleshooting


 
 Site Index 


'Yaquina Head'
TLF #1 Negative Emulsion Exposed to Positive

Whole Plate (6.5" x 8.5")


"Exposure

THE AMERICAN PHOTOGRAPHY EXPOSURE-TABLES. —
Find numbers for subject, stop, light, month and hour, and plate.  Add them, refer to table (page 60), and give exposure indicated."

Photographic Facts and Formulas, by E. J. Wall.  American Photographic Publishing Co., 1924, p51.


From Photographic Facts and Formulas

Avoiding the 'Spurious Precision' Trap

It is misleading in the extreme to assign a firm ISO number to an old colorblind or orthochromatic emulsion.  As I have addressed in previous sections, the old emulsions respond differently than the modern miracles we've grown up with.  Any emulsion produced without a gamut of panchromatic sensitizers and industrial cooking controls will exhibit a range of 'speeds' — determined by the temperature of the light, the color and reflectance of the subject and the inevitable variability of each handmade batch, and the developer used.  The old emulsions are best described qualitatively and with an assumed '~' sign. 

For better — and for worse — modern film emulsions have a lot of leeway for exposure and development.  The bright side of this is obvious: it’s pretty hard to make an exposure/development mistake serious enough to ruin an image.  The disadvantage is the loss of control previous generations of photographers took for granted.

The following sets of images cover three overlapping areas of artistic control/potential pitfalls (two sides of the same coin) — exposure, development and filter factors.

Pentax K20 Digital Color File, Color File Desaturated, Color File Desaturated and Inverted

Determining 'Speed'.

The histogram on a digital camera is the best way I know to understand the old emulsions. Unless you are deliberately choosing otherwise, you are aiming for a smooth, balanced bell curve that doesn't compress or clip either the shadows or the highlights.  Visualize a histogram when you look at the bottom row of the ColorChecker chart.  A nice 'curve' in our case is six, easily distinguishable density blocks.  The six plates below illustrate a number of overlapping issues that influence the exposure curve of a negative.

All of the plates are from the same batch of TLF #1 emulsion, exposed on the same afternoon in early May, at sea level on the central Oregon Coast (latitude 44° N). Two different modern lenses and two different filters were used.  The bench was in full light, facing south, on a bright overcast day. The plates were all processed in the same developer (Defender55Dwr, 1:1).

All of these facts are integral to determining the 'speed' of a plate.

Top left: #8 yellow filter, underexposed, overdeveloped.  Top right: #8 yellow filter, good exposure and development.  Middle left: No filter, just a little overexposed.  Middle right: UV filter, overexposed.  Bottom left: UV filter, +overexposed.  Bottom right: No filter, ++overexposed.


Curve Control

The six plates go from one exposure extreme to the other.  The first plate is very much underexposed and the last plate is very much overexposed.  There is quite a bit to learn here.  All the plates were photographed on a light table and output with no manipulation beyond inverting and cropping.

This plate was made with a #8 yellow filter at 8 sec and f/32 => 1-1/2x the correct exposure without a filter. That would have been about right with modern pan film, but the colorblind plate is seriously under-exposed.  I pushed the development to 12 minutes from the normal 8 minutes and all I accomplished was developer fog.  Still, there is good separation in the high values and the bear shows all its detail.

#8 yellow filter. 15 sec, f/32 (3x normal exposure without a filter). There is excellent separation of values.  Note, though, that the shade behind the bench is barely recorded and Fred the frog is a little thin.

No filter. 6 sec, f/32 (4 to 5 sec would have been better.)  The shaded areas recorded well, but the high values compressed.  The detail in the white bear is lost.  Fortunately, the plate will print beautifully on variable contrast paper.

UV filter. 15 sec, f/32.  Here’s where it gets really interesting and a bit tricky.  Note that the white bear has just tipped into solarization (the reversal of negative to positive due to overexposure.)  The bear is the only indication on the plate.  There is obvious high value compression, but no more so than on the previous plate.  If you weren’t looking for the problem, you might hold the plate up and guess that it was underexposed because the bear looks light.  But, more exposure would not be the solution.  Just look at the next plate.

UV filter. 30 sec, f/32.  The white bear has tipped completely.  Take a close look at the ColorChecker chart.  Most of the values have flipped.  Note especially the gray scale.

No Filter. 15 sec, f/32.  Note that although the UV filter doesn't change the color recording characteristics of the emulsion, it does block total exposure (It doesn't have that effect on modern pan film.)  This plate is more overexposed — with less time — than the plate above.


A Positive Plate.

'Yaquina Head', the image at the top of this page, is solarization pushed to the limit.  The entire plate (on the right) flipped uniformly.  Although it is flat, the density is good.  To produce the digital print, all I had to do was photograph the plate on a light table, crop the outer edges, apply a shallow 'S-curve' and a bit of selective 'burn' and 'dodge'.




Filter Comparison: Y8 and UV.

From the left: NO filter, #8 Yellow, UV.   Although there is highlight compression on the no-filter and UV-filter prints, it is easy to see that the color renditions are almost identical and very different from the plate exposed with a yellow filter.  I need to get a batch of plates up into the mountains on a bright summer day and see if the UV filter has more influence under those circumstances.

Also, it will be interesting to see how the addition of various sensitizing dyes influences the behavior of filters.  Soon.




MORE TO COME:  The addition of sensitizers to the emulsion.



Copyright © The Light Farm